Construction Student Team Consulting*

Construction Student Team Consulting (CSTC) gives construction graduate students experience in interacting with construction industry people to apply the students’ knowledge to real industry problems. It also helps industry clients identify problems they face and it provides fresh insights and solutions that improve clients’ practices.

CSTC projects were initiated in the Fall Semester in 1994 as part of a new course, CEE 530 – Construction Professional Practice Seminar, which is required of all students in the Master of Engineering (MEng) in Construction Engineering and Management (CE&M) at the University of Michigan. In its first four years, which ended in April 1998, CSTC teams completed 19 projects for nine industry clients (see last page of nomination for list of clients and projects). Professor Robert I. Carr created the Construction Professional Practice Seminar and its CSTC, and he has recruited its industry clients and supervised the work of all teams.

Most university construction programs have had internships, coop programs, and/or summer work programs. Many individual students and teams have worked with industry people in research to solve industry problems. Many business schools have recently initiated student team consulting programs, as described in a recent cover story in Fortune. However, the CSTC at the University of Michigan is the first such formal student team consulting program in construction.

Students take CEE 530 in two successive semesters, starting in either September or January. In their first semester in CEE 530 students form teams of two to four students. Each team selects and contacts an industry client and meets with the client to identify a client problems on which the team can work and develop a project plan. In the second semester, each team performs the work in its project plan to solve its client’s problem. Each team prepares a report for the client and makes an oral presentation to the client and to the Construction Professional Practice Seminar.

Its clients’ implementation of student team products and their repeated participation prove the success of the CSTC program. For example, the first year’s projects successfully

  1. determined contract document inaccuracies and scheduled contractors’ and subcontractors’ crews on hospital renovation for ADA for O’Neal Construction,
  2. improved the project conceptual planning program at Detroit Edison, and
  3. developed a plan for removing and transporting a historic bridge, some of which items were implemented by the Merriman Construction.
Since then, General Motors has implemented (1) criteria for matching types of construction contracts to types of projects and (2) contractor prequalification and evaluation database developed by CSTC. CSTC recommendations improved Merriman Construction and O’Neal Construction marketing. Detroit Edison has implemented a computerized contractor evaluation system and is updating its construction general conditions of contract based on CSTC reports. O’Neal Construction superintendents use the "Project Superintendent Manual", and Merriman Construction operating engineers use crane data sheets in crane maintenance and operation. Ann Arbor contractors and developers now regularly use the City of Ann Arbor Development Manual developed by CSTC. The University of Michigan adjusted its contract administration policies based on CSTC recommendations on substantial completion and causes of project delay.

Students are universally enthusiastic about CSTC and consider it a major benefit of their graduate education. The number of CSTC client candidates continues to grow (Turner Construction is added for 1998-99), and clients compete for CSTC. The University of Michigan program proves the benefits of a CSTC program, and we encourage other universities to initiate similar programs to benefit their students and the industry.

Construction Student Team Consulting Project Format

First Semester: Students form student teams. Teams select and contact industry clients (contractor, owner, architect, engineer, union, etc). Teams and client select a project topic and produce a project plan for work in the second semester. Project represents 30 hours of work per team member spread over the semester. Team makes presentation of the plan to the Construction Professional Practice Seminar.

Second Semester: Each student team works with its client to address the client’s problem or to improve the client’s function. The team prepares a report for client and makes a 30-minute presentation to the client and at the Construction Professional Practice Seminar. Project represents 90 hours of work per team member spread over the semester.

Past Construction Student Team Consulting Projects

Winter 1995
bulletO’Neal Construction Co.: Scheduling UM Hospital ADA Renovation
bulletDetroit Edison: Project Conceptual Planning
bulletMerriman Construction Co.: Removal, and Transport of Belleville Bridge Superstructure
Fall 1995
bulletMerriman Construction CO.: Market Survey
bulletO’Neal Construction Co.: Marketing Plan
Winter 1996
bulletGeorge Auch Co.: Select Submittal Tracking Software
bulletDetroit Edison: Contractor Evaluation
bulletGeneral Motors Corp: Criteria for Types of Construction Contracts
Fall 1996
bulletAdministrative Controls Management: ISO 9000 Criteria and Qualification
bulletO’Neal Construction Co.: Design-Build Opportunities
Winter 1997
bulletUniversity of Michigan: Administration of Substantial Completion
bulletDetroit Edison: Evaluating General Conditions of Contract
Fall 1997
bulletGeneral Motors Corp: Contractor Prequalification and Evaluation Database
bulletAdministrative Controls Management: Project Management Trends in Construction
Winter 1998
bulletO’Neal Construction Co.: Project Superintendent Manual
bulletMerriman Construction Co.: Equipment Policies for Older Cranes
bulletUniversity of Michigan: Causes of Project Delay
bulletWashtenaw Contractors Association: City of Ann Arbor Development Manual
bulletOperating Engineers Local 324: Federal Control on Grant
Fall 1998+
bulletGeneral Motors Corp.: Capital Projects Cost Estimating Database
bulletGeorge W. Auch Co.: Fundamental Guide to Professional Construction
bulletAdministrative Controls Management: Expenditure Tracking for FAA Natural Disaster Repairs
Winter 1999
bullet· Detroit Edison: Improving Construction of Electrical Substations
bullet· Merriman Construction Co.: Daily Construction Reports Via the Internet
bullet· O’Neal Construction Co.: Delay of NSF Headquarter Project
bullet· Turner Construction Co.: Office 2000 Project: A Virtual Construction Office
· Washtenaw Contractors Association: Construction Safety Manual
Fall 1999
bullet· DeMattia Group: Project Collaboration Networks for Construction Management
Winter 2000
bullet· Merriman Construction Co.: Work-Site Safety Checklist
bullet· Administrative Controls Management: Trends Domestic Construction Claims 
bullet· University of Michigan: Construction Plan Review Process
bullet· Turner Construction Co.: Analysis of Below-Slab Plumbing at Parke-Davis
Fall 2000
bullet· DeMattia Group: Project to be selected
bullet· General Motors Corp.: Project to be selected

* This is the Nomination of Construction Student Team Consulting for the 1999 NOVA Award, which was identified in an October 26, 1998 of Engineering News Record Editorial as an innovative program "that gives construction grad students real experience with industry practitioners."

+ Projects in Fall 1998 and later were completed after September 15, 1998 and were not part of the Nova Award Nomination.

Univ. of Michigan | College of Engineering | Civil & Env. Eng. | CEM | Acrobat Reader
This page last updated 03/17/00 by RICarr